« Too good not to share | Main | Treppenwitz: The short school bus of weblogs »

Sunday, November 11, 2007

Hello Pot? You're black!

Jerusalem Post columnist Larry Derfner is laughable on so many levels that I've generally avoided mentioning him here... except to occasionally poke fun at his Groucho Marx-esque eyebrows (which look like they were drawn onto the stock photo that accompanies his columns with grease pencil).

Also... what kind of writer calls his column "Rattling the Cage"?  My guess is that it is the kind of arrogant writer who feels it is his duty to disabuse the readers of their dearly held, but terribly flawed beliefs.

Well, now it's my turn to share a few hard truths with Mr. Derfner.

This past week he wrote a piece entitled 'The 90 minute hate' about the Beitar Yeushalayim fan's less-than-PC behavior during the Rabin moment of silence... and the elegant solution he proposes for punishing those cheeky low-lifes.   In it he leads off with the following incredible two paragraphs:

"If I could, I would outlaw soccer, or at least limit it to pick-up games with no more than a half-dozen spectators. What happened this week on the anniversary of Rabin's assassination, when Betar Jerusalem fans booed during the minute of silence and sang songs of praise to Yigal Amir, was just another expression of the sort of thing that goes on all the time at soccer games not only in Israel, but all over the world.

It's called mob fascism. Nationalist, racist, violent human herds doing their thing. It's not clear why this is so, maybe because the game resembles primitive warfare, but soccer attracts these kinds of people and inspires this kind of activity like no other sport. I'm not saying that all soccer fans are fascist scum, of course, but I am saying that all fascist scum seem to be soccer fans."

No, um... actually Larry, your opening line "If I could, I would outlaw..." is more fascist than anything those beer sotted fans could have managed.  Classic fascism is exactly that nasty tendency you've demonstrated towards thought control, censorship and authoritarian quashing of anything that doesn't support the party line. 

Fascism fears freedom of speech/expression above all else and enjoys the notion that the government can forge a kind of national consensus through sheer force of will.  Clearly there is no national consensus about Rabin's beatification, so folks like Larry seem to feel that the great unwashed masses need to be taught a lesson!

Pay attention Larry... besides sounding suspiciously like a kid who never got picked for soccer at recess time, you also seem to have drunk deeply from the Kool Aid with the rest of the fascists in our leadership who just woke up and realized, "holy crap, you mean it isn't against the law to boo and heckle at a sporting event?  We need to do something about that... I want somebody punished!"

I'm sorely tempted to paste the whole article here... there's just so much to pick over and lampoon in what he's written.  But I won't.  Go read it... it's an eye opener.   He rants and raves for several paragraphs about how soccer is a global breeding ground for fascism and how soccer fans (who he tellingly refers to a "these kinds of people") are all animals. 

What he is really saying is that he doesn't much like the smell of the earthier fans who follow the sport.  It is a classist rant that reveals much about this so-called journalist's prejudices.  It shows how completely he has fallen into lockstep with the lily-white secular Ashkenazi leadership on the left... as if to say, "How dare those swarthy low class people boo our hero... they seem to have forgotten their place!"

The only saving grace to Derfner's piece is that in the heat of his condemnations, he openly and explicitly accuses Beitar owner Arkady Gaydamak of money laundering, illegal arms sales "and a slew of other big time felonies", apparently forgetting that:

a)  We live in a democracy where a journalist can't actually say someone committed a crime without using the word 'allegedly' until a trial has been held and a guilty verdict returned.

b)  No such trial or verdict has been held/returned for any of the crimes Mr. Gaydamak is alleged by Larry to have committed.

c)  Mr. Gaydamak has enough big time lawyers on retainer that the lawsuits are probably already piling up on the Jerusalem Post's doorstep like blue paper snow.

So besides sitting back and enjoying the spectacle of Larry Derfner being chased through the Israeli courts for the next few years (or until his money gives out, whichever comes first), I want to offer one parting gift to the man with the uni-brow... because I'm a giver: 

Fascism isn't about a bunch of working stiffs - a demographic that Americans affectionately refer to as 'Joe Six-Pack - yelling obscenities or acting in bad taste at a soccer match.  Fascism is "an authoritarian political ideology (generally tied to a mass movement) that considers individual and other societal interests subordinate to the interests of the state" *... a definition that not only fits the government's actions towards dissenting opinions, but also your own intolerance of anyone who doesn't share your tennis-ethic world-view.

Before I go, let me point you to a wonderful post by my good friend Ben Horin who, as usual, has condensed the pure essence of what I could only dream of writing on my most rational day... and then said it even better and more concisely.

* Source

Posted by David Bogner on November 11, 2007 | Permalink

TrackBack

TrackBack URL for this entry:
https://www.typepad.com/services/trackback/6a00d8341c581e53ef00e5505269a68834

Listed below are links to weblogs that reference Hello Pot? You're black!:

Comments

Feed You can follow this conversation by subscribing to the comment feed for this post.

I read about the two-game ban and I could not understand it. In my old country (Argentina) a team would be banned from playing home games either because the stadium was found to be falling apart, or for punishment for some serious incident between the "barras bravas", the hard-core fans of each team who will try to meet either before or after the game to finalize some unfinished business like stealing the other teams flags. But I never heard of a home game ban due to the fans booing for political reasons. What is this going to solve? next year the fans will boo even louder, and what is the soccer association going to do then? ban the team for four games?

Posted by: David S | Nov 11, 2007 3:17:03 AM

Whenever Larry Derfner writes about Israel's social ills- rude children, Holocaust survivors living in poverty, etc., I agree with him wholeheartedly. But whenever he writes about politics, I read those columns to get a good laugh and to practice my eyerolls. His beliefs are just beyond me.

Posted by: RR | Nov 11, 2007 11:26:20 AM

Actually, Trep, if you re-read Derfner's exact words about Gaydamak, then read the list of his French indictments, you'll see that Derfner has not violated any libel rules that I know of.

Posted by: dfb1968 | Nov 11, 2007 2:12:59 PM

I don't go to ice hockey games - professional or my husband's B-league - because I get really depressed about humanity when I see men and women cheering while people fist fight. I don't want to ban the sport. I just don't watch it. I think they all need counseling. But then again, don't know too many people who couldn't use a little.

Posted by: Alice | Nov 11, 2007 3:03:38 PM

Derfner lives in an alternative universe.

I wrote here a response to his idiocy that there is no place in Israel where Jewish and Arab children might play together as they would in other countries. I, of course, made sure to provide a list of places where my (settler) kids play along side Arab children.

But in his universe that can't occur.

I wrote here about the mass left-wing indoctrination attempts that occur at sports game and movie theaters. And here showing how the Left actually helped instigate the response at the game in question.

Posted by: JoeSettler | Nov 11, 2007 8:25:20 PM

Wow, talking about generalizing. I guess he'd have to put my entire family along with those fascists, given how we're all fans of the games (and some of my male relatives either have attended or do attend or would attend if given an opportunity to see a decent game, one of these horrible, horrible events). Aside from the little fact that I myself like to catch a glimpse of this dangerous, anti-social game on TV whenever I have time... Besides the very disturbing trend that you have outlined in your post, there's also the logical fallacy of blaming the game for bad behavior of people, who would have probably found another outlet for their immaturity elsewhere, if the game didn't even exist. (Yeah, like we don't have baseball fans going wild and getting drunk and screaming all sorts of things during the season??? Come on!)

Posted by: Irina | Nov 11, 2007 9:21:53 PM

Anyone reading JPOST shouldn't be offended by outrages BS. To be fair, I also want to point out that the whole sector of english-language publications in Israel suffers from quality issues.
I don't know anyone personally who seriously reads this stuff.

Posted by: dave | Nov 11, 2007 11:48:16 PM

Whatever his alleged crimes, I could only agree with Gaydamak that a sporting event was hardly the venue for a memorial for Rabin. Sports are accompanied by enough rivalry without trying to introduce politics into the mix, and to this day, Rabin's death is nothing if not political. I can't imagine Americans trying to enforce a moment of silence to remember JFK's assassination at a sporting event. There are times and places for things, and a venue which lends itself to heavy drinking, colorful language, and the odd brawl is hardly the time or the place for a solemn occasion like a moment of silence. Trying to enforce solemnity on a sporting event was doomed from the start, and should not have been attempted.

Posted by: Shimshonit | Nov 12, 2007 8:48:11 AM

David S... In short, it is anti-democratic. Natan Sharansky said it best when he described the town square test to see if you live in a democracy. Simply put, if you can stand in the Town square and criticize the government or anything connected with it without fear of reprisal, you live in a democracy. If not... you don't. Booeing Rabin at a soccer match is a pretty good replication of the town hall test... and Israel failed.

RR... The problem is that he writes with the sensibilities of an immigrant but the callousness of an insider. a bad combination.

dfb1968... Damn, I was looking forward to some fun. :-)

Alice... Hockey is a sport? News to me. :-)

JoeSettler ... Unfortunately he is published in our universe. I don't have a problem with lefty journalists writing for the Post. in fact I feel like if someone gets me steamed every couple of days in my regular paper it is probably a sign that they have balanced reporting. But Derfner is just pathetic and has no redeeming journalistic value to offer.

Irina... Far be it from me to criticize him for writing an illogical rant. Heck, I invented the genre. But what he wrote was actually dangerous.

dave... Well now you do. Howdy! :-)

Shimshonit... Several people have suggested that it was actually doomed from the start and that the moment of silence was designed to get a shocking reaction.

Posted by: treppenwitz | Nov 12, 2007 3:04:13 PM

The comments to this entry are closed.