« No one to blame but myself | Main | An inherited case of ' the wants' »
Tuesday, May 01, 2007
Who Needs Neosporin®?
One of the nice things about keeping an on-line journal and sharing things about my hobby (beekeeping) is that sharp-eyed readers periodically forward articles about bees that they think might be of interest to me (they're usually right).
This morning I awoke to find that a long-time treppenwitz reader out in Ohio had sent me a couple of articles from 'The Economist' relating to bees. The timing couldn't have been better since I had a long meeting scheduled for this morning (which had almost nothing to do with me) and I was desperate for some reading material.
One of the articles was a nice little wrap-up of the latest to do with the mysterious disappearance of a huge portion of the world's bee population last winter. Not much there I didn't already know, but still... nice to stay up-to-date with that sort of thing.
The other article was so fascinating that I felt like I should share the salient points here.
Long story short, the article (entitled 'A Sticky Solution') discusses the fact that honey is proving to be quite effective in fighting antibiotic-resistant 'super bugs' such as those found in many hospitals today.
When I first began keeping bees, several of the books I read mentioned in passing that before the age of antibiotic cremes and antiseptic sprays/ointments, honey had been used for millenia as a very effective wound dressing. In fact, there is evidence that Roman soldiers used honey as a battle dressing to fight off infection and assist with healing.
However, in all of the bee-culture books where such things were mentioned, this type of factoid was relegated to the status of folk wisdom and no real medical reason was ever given why honey should work as a wound dressing.
The Economist article steps in and fills in the gaps quite nicely with the following explanation:
"Research in Australia and New Zealand suggests that honey heals because it attacks bacteria in several different ways at once. Because honey is composed of saturated sugars, it sucks up water, depriving bacteria of the liquid they need to survive and multiply. As bees make honey they secrete glucoseoxidase, an enzyme that releases the bleach hydrogen peroxide when it comes into contact with wound liquids. The low-level but frequent release of this chemical ensures regular anti-bacterial washes of the wound."
Look, I'm, not going to turn my back on anti-biotic for serious stuff such a systemic infections... and I'm sure the medical community isn't about to do so either. But I have to say that from here on in, when anyone in the family gets a cut or scrape, I may just reach for the honey jar rather than that tube of Neosporin® in the medicine cabinet.
UPDATE: Everyone's favorite blogging anesthesiologist (the proprietor of Book of Joe) was kind enough to send me another link to even more compelling information about honey's medicinal applications as a wound/burn dressing. Thanks Joe!
Posted by David Bogner on May 1, 2007 | Permalink
TrackBack
TrackBack URL for this entry:
https://www.typepad.com/services/trackback/6a00d8341c581e53ef00e5503ed2548833
Listed below are links to weblogs that reference Who Needs Neosporin®?:
Comments
You can follow this conversation by subscribing to the comment feed for this post.
I learnt heaps about bees here: http://www.superbee.com.au/
Aside from the many varieties of honey and their exhibitions and demonstrations, I vaguely remember they did have information about the healing properties of honey.
Posted by: Sarah | May 1, 2007 2:44:20 PM
A friend recommended locally-produced honey eaten daily over the winter as a way to get the body used to spring pollens and fight allergies. Not sure if it works, I started too late this year, though my allergies seem to be better than in the past.
Posted by: Alan | May 1, 2007 4:53:11 PM
Sarah... Thanks for the link. It is blocked by my company for some reason, but I'll check it when I get home.
Alan... That is exaclty the reason I got into beekeeping. My lovely wife used to have allergy attacks in the spring so bad that she would sometimes be hospitalized. Her allergist suggested that rather than having him give her shots every week to desensitize her, that she find some local honey and start taking it daily in early January through the spring bloom. It worked like a charm in Connecticut. When we moved here to Israel I couldn't find a beekeeper in my area so I started producing honey with my own bees. While it hasn't eliminated all of Zahava's allergy symptoms (some blooming plants and trees are of no interest to bees so their pollen wouldn't be present in the honey), it is worlds better than before.
Posted by: treppenwitz | May 1, 2007 5:02:46 PM
It may work... but the idea of rubbing honey on a cut just sounds too obnoxiously sticky to me!
And c'mon, who you kiddin'? You got into to be able to wear that fetchin' outfit! ;)
Posted by: val | May 1, 2007 5:44:24 PM
It may work... but the idea of rubbing honey on a cut just sounds too obnoxiously sticky to me!
And c'mon, who you kiddin'? You got into the whole bee thing to be able to wear that fetchin' outfit! ;)
Posted by: val | May 1, 2007 5:45:02 PM
Would regular supermarket (cooked) honey work as well as the raw honey available in health-food stores? Before you give us medical advice, please be specific!
Posted by: Sarah | May 1, 2007 7:40:35 PM
Not to be a honey party pooper.... although honey may have antibacterial properties, it is still recommended not to give honey to children under the age of 1 year due to risks of infant botulism.......
Posted by: David | May 2, 2007 2:12:30 AM
Are you guys serious?
Posted by: miss Worldwide | May 2, 2007 3:04:30 AM
its funny to hear about people's hobbies when you never would have expected it.
"it is still recommended not to give honey to children under the age of 1 year due to risks of infant botulism"
actually the language they used in school with us this semester was much stronger in this regard than just "not recommended." don't do it. period.
and for that matter . . .
"rather than that tube of Neosporin"
for that population neosporin is often not recommended and a safer bet is polymixin or just plain bacitracin.
Posted by: ari kinsberg | May 2, 2007 8:10:10 AM
You want to come and pick up the hive that just swarmed onto our property?
The beekeeper didn't come around for almost 4 weeks and apparently missed the fact that this hive was not happy. (It is not a split, his hive is empty).
With family that has bee sting allergies, it would be really nice to have it gone.
Posted by: Holly | May 2, 2007 11:45:55 AM
honey is wonderful! Any suggestions as to whether it could help exema? I'll try anything at this point...
Posted by: nrg | May 2, 2007 1:07:38 PM
just like that? you mention the bees have disappeared and don't tell us where they went??? another dinosaur meisseh only instead of HUGE we have tiny? not fair trepp...not fair...ps i love the honey healing business
Posted by: marallyn | May 2, 2007 1:48:30 PM
Val... Yeah, cuz there is nothing more fashionable than a bee suit and veil. :-)
Sarah... Yes, the properties discussed in the use of honey as a wound/burn dressing should work with any honey. However if you want to use honey to ease the symptoms of seasonal allergies, it must be raw, local honey.
David... We're talking about spreading it on the skin, not letting them eat it! :-)
miss Worldwide... I never joke about bees. :-)
ari kinsberg... Again, I don't recommend letting kids of any age eat neosporin. This is a discussion of wound dressing only.
Holly... You should know that a swarm in your yard really poses very little danger to you or your family. Away from their hive, bees have almost no defensive instinct and tend to be very docile. If you've ever seen circus performers with a 'beard of bees', that is an example of how docile swarms of bees can be. Still, your local beekeeper should have been more responsive to your fears.
nrg... It couldn't hurt. :-)
marallyn... Google 'Hive Collapse Disorder' and you will get a ton of info on the problem.
Posted by: treppenwitz | May 2, 2007 3:35:59 PM
"I don't recommend letting kids of any age eat neosporin. This is a discussion of wound dressing only."
i can't tell if you were kidding here, but i was referring to wound dressing (and obviously not to oral consumption).
Posted by: ari kinsberg | May 2, 2007 4:50:18 PM
ALL honey is 'raw', it isn't cooked or filtered. It's heated a little to prevent crystallization on the store shelf. Even then, sometimes that doesn't work. And it's strained to remove stuff that shouldn't be there, like wax bits.
Posted by: Joel | May 6, 2007 8:07:09 AM
ALL honey is 'raw', it isn't cooked or filtered. It's heated a little to prevent crystallization on the store shelf. Even then, sometimes that doesn't work. And it's strained to remove stuff that shouldn't be there, like wax bits.
Posted by: Joel | May 6, 2007 8:07:34 AM
ari kinsberg... Your the doc. I didn't know you could get botulism from a cut.
Joel... The process of heating it and filtering it (yes, commercial outfits do both) renders honey less 'raw' in the eyes of those who seek it for its pollen and propolis content.
Posted by: treppenwitz | May 6, 2007 1:00:46 PM
Hey - I was going to beekeep in Jerusalem. I've finally gotten off your site where to get the bee equipment and stuff. Thanks!
Posted by: Sara | May 14, 2007 6:17:40 PM