« …Lifnei Iver | Main | Not getting the point 101 »
Wednesday, September 08, 2004
Wanting vs. Missing
The other day I wrote that I could now officially say that I wanted for nothing here in our new country. I was happy… I had just ‘discovered’ a source for really good freshly roasted coffee beans… I was giddy… it was clearly too much for somebody.
As has become the trend (just look at yesterday’s comments) someone had to call me on it and demanded to know if there is truly nothing I miss from ‘the old country’.
This is just proof that people don’t pay attention when they read. I never said (or even implied) that I didn’t miss things from the states… I simply said that I didn’t want for anything here. There is a difference… a big one, in fact.
One implies that I have everything I need (which I do). The other suggests that I have undergone some sort of brainwashing/deprogramming which has wiped away a lifetime’s worth of likes, dislikes and experiences… not gonna happen, people.
On the one hand, a very important part of a successful absorption into any society is letting go of many of the things that were previously taken for granted.
For instance… the simple pleasure of not having to bag one’s own groceries… that is something I always took for granted, but which I have learned to live without here.
Another good example would be driving to work without a gun next to the gearshift. Now, granted there were sections of my old commute (especially in the Bronx) where I sometimes wished I had something, other than my charm, for self protection… but for the most part, I have made my peace with this small inconvenience as well, and barely notice it. I’m sure there are other equally apt examples, but for now you get the idea.
But just plain missing things… that is something that is always there (like a phantom itch), which will always separate me from Israelis who have never lived abroad.
Take, for example, diners. Granted, it’s been a very long time since I’ve ordered a BLT with a chocolate milkshake (with the leftover shake in the metal blender cup) or a turkey club on white toast (heavy on the mayo) in a diner… what with keeping kosher, and all. Even after I started keeping kosher (and especially during my Route 66 trip) I frequently popped into vintage diners to order a cup of coffee, a couple of hard-boiled eggs (in the shell, thank you) and maybe one of those little single-serving boxes of Kellogg’s breakfast cereal. You see, that was the beauty of a diner… the real ones were open 24 hours and served breakfast at any time of the day or night, no questions asked. Try finding a comfortable place to sit drinking coffee at 3:00AM in Israel!
Another thing… New England in the Fall (especially the Merritt Parkway) is something else that will always be there… calling to me the way an open package of chocolate calls to my wife. Since I don’t see myself making scheduled trips to the states in the Fall (what with the kids in school, the Jewish holidays, work, etc.), I have resigned myself to looking at pictures and webcams of the fall foliage.
Xmas songs. I’ll bet you didn’t see that one coming! Yes, I’ll admit it… I love that time of year when all the radio stations (and mall loudspeakers) spew an endless stream of these hokey old songs. Heck, most of 'em were written or performed by Jews, so stop staring at me that way! Let’s face it… I don’t care if you’re Sihk, Buddhist, Rastafarian or Druid… you can’t grow up in New England and not develop a soft spot for all those sappy carols. ‘Jingle Bell Rock’, yeah baby! I guess Internet radio will have to suffice.
What else?
I have an idea… why don’t some of the Israelis (or any expats living abroad) chime in with the things you don’t absolutely need… but, which in weak moments, you sorely miss.
The comments section is open for business.
Posted by David Bogner on September 8, 2004 | Permalink
TrackBack
TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://www.typepad.com/services/trackback/6a00d8341c581e53ef00e5503e69ef8833
Listed below are links to weblogs that reference Wanting vs. Missing:
Comments
Woo hoo! I'm first!
Things I don't need but miss:
Manhattan during a snowfall
Entenmann's
Talbots (actually, I need Talbots)
New England Foliage
Payless Shoe Source
The New York City subway system
Financial statements in English (um, need that)
manila folders
rolling hills with grass and trees on them instead of just rocks and sand.
That's all I can think of. I've basically adjusted to the things here, at least so far.
I'm interested in knowing what Israelis miss when they leave Israel.
Posted by: sarah | Sep 8, 2004 2:44:18 PM
This post brought totally unexpected tears into my eyes. I don't miss Germany but I DO miss rolls! Crunchy-crunchy totally empty rolls! German bread with its strong taste. Rhubarber from my mother's garden. Red currants. Gooseberries. All these sour delicious garden berries you can't have in Israel. And fresh asparagus - aaah. Only with butter, nothing else. In May, Germans eat asparagus for every meal.
Apart from my primitive palate, is there anything German I miss? German bookstores, full of unsuspected old quality books - not only nylon-wrapped bestsellers that disappear faster than a roll from my plate. Ecological concern: separating the garbage, clean streets, clean forests, clean beaches.
And then: the border to Holland where you can buy the saltiest liquorice ever. It burns your tongue but yes it's good. There we are at food again...
Anyway thank you for asking! (No I won't go back not even for the asparagus.)
Posted by: Lila | Sep 8, 2004 2:59:47 PM
I will be sure and post some fall foliage pics for you David. Its gonna be an early winter in N.E. this year, the early trees are already starting to change!
Too bad I can't do a scratch-n-sniff for you of that lovely autumn scent.
Posted by: Lisa | Sep 8, 2004 3:29:16 PM
You shouldn'ta done that. Now I've gotten all sappy just thinking about hot summer rain in New York and corned beef and pastrami on club at Bernstein's, Saturday night 1:00 AM. (The rain is actually yucky and Bernstein's is long gone but that's nostalgia for you.)
Posted by: Ben Chorin | Sep 8, 2004 4:12:59 PM
Sitting in an old fashioned English pub, log fire blazing on a cold winter day nursing a pint of good English beer, with a packet of Salt and Vinegar and a whisky chaser.....
Posted by: gil ben mori | Sep 8, 2004 10:23:05 PM
Well, I could make a list of all of the things I miss because I live in LA and not Israel.
I sometimes wish that I could move the countries closer together. It is just too far to go for a short visit, not to mention $$$.
One day I'll have to make the move.
Posted by: Jack | Sep 8, 2004 10:32:06 PM
OOPPSS, sorry about the blank post. I thought I was the only closet carol lover. My kids are aghast that I know all the words.
Just think for a minute about what your kids memories are going to be like.... can you imagine, they will probably be nostalgic for sand and rock.
Posted by: marjorie | Sep 9, 2004 12:12:48 AM
Ok David,
and here i was thinking... it is embarrasing to go to a store anytime after halloween and know ALL The words to the songs they sing. I guess that is a part of my childhood that I will miss when I make Aliyah, but still the tradeoff is amazing. My friend the Orthodox Straight Jewish Theater Queen (which is a frighteningly apt description) btw: and I used to sit there at the Shabbat table and sing for hours, occasionally bursting into a frenzied rendition of "Rudolph the red nosed Regenhirsch" As far as fall in N.E goes, I am with you there. I spent my formative years in Burlinton, VT. and there is just nothing like it!
Posted by: Faye | Sep 9, 2004 1:46:47 AM
What a nice collection of things missed... based on what people miss, I'd say most of you, like me, want for very little in life. Lucky us.
Posted by: David | Sep 10, 2004 6:10:54 PM
I grew up in boropark but I can dig the missing of the holiday songs--and I dont mean maos tzur, for years, I used to watch the burnring of the yule log on WPIX about 1/2 way thru I'd turn down the sound and just watch the picture to the strains of Miles Kinda blue. in fact I juust oucked up a Klezmer Christmans album. I dontknwo what it is about that time of year that makes me want to pay retail.
Re the whole foliage thing--I can see missing it, which is why I love Sukkos @ the Wak--the air is so crisp it snaps like a pretzel stick, the colors around you are deep browns and oranges like something Joseph Aboud designed (so sue me, I'm a meterosexual)but hey missing the preceding is a small price to pay for what you & your family have in exchange
Posted by: SHLOIMI ASH | Sep 13, 2004 9:16:11 PM
Shloimi... no question we got the clean end of the stick... but just as my wife knows I can't be left alone in the state of Maine (I miss lobster that much), there are a bunch of other sensory things that will always be missing.
Thanks for stopping by.
Posted by: David | Sep 13, 2004 10:13:00 PM












